Columnist – John Sammon
Do you love it when presidents and politicians and military leaders resort to vague meaningless, indefinable terminology to promote wars they believe in? Two words stand out. Win, and turn around.
We are going to win in Afghanistan the president says, even though a troop reduction is supposedly scheduled in two years. The military will likely talk him out of it, and we will be in Afghanistan for 30 years.
When Obama says we are going to WIN, what does he mean? He never elaborates. Just like former presidents never did. Obama says he is for change, but apparently not that much change. What does WIN mean? What conditions have to be present for us to WIN?
One possibility would be that every member of the Taliban comes out of hiding and marches in a single file line to Kabul to a jail and before entering, lays down their obsolete weapons. I do not think that is going to happen. Do you?
Another possibility is that the Taliban sign a surrender document just like the old way of wars, assuming there is a leader of the Taliban all the Taliban could agree would be authorized to sign such a document. The Taliban would then cease to exist and they would become either prisoners of or welfare recipients of American overlordship and or patronage.
I do not think that is going to happen. Do you?
Another scenario would have the US occupy ground with the understanding that even 300,000 troops can not occupy all of Afghanistan, as there are millions of occupants of Kabul alone. The Taliban would occupy those rural remote areas we do not.
We could claim we have WON, but that would be a hollow proclamation.
Another possibility would be a Waterloo style military victory in which a majority of the Taliban are annihilated out in the open in a set piece battle in which the Taliban allow us to use our overwhelming firepower to overwhelm them.
I do not think that is going to happen. Do you?
Then the question is, HOW CAN WE WIN? The president does not know, and if he was honest in this case he would admit it. The American people do not demand to be told how we can win. What is WIN? We will never know.
We have discovered huge mineral deposits in Afghanistan that we are now greedily eyeing. If we win the war and exploit these natural resources, I suppose it would be a case of WIN WIN.
Instead, we have this silly foolish game where the silly former general made fun of Obama and Biden in an interview in of all things a rock and roll magazine (an appropriate place), and was replaced by General Betrayus, the man whom the media said TURNED AROUND the war in Iraq.
This is based on the thinking that since he did it in Iraq, he can do it again in Afghanistan. One size fits all, even though they are completely different countries. Turn things around. What does TURN AROUND mean? It is like the word WIN. We do not know.
The main thing for Obama is to preserve the allusion of solidarity over the war. That we are all in agreement.
I think TURN THINGS AROUND means loosely, that even though we have not won in Iraq, things are not as bad as they once were. Using common sense, which is an oxymoron when it comes to matters of war, you can not have WON, not decisively, if the best you could do is to make things not as bad as they were before, or in other words, TURN THINGS AROUND.
What if General Grant had only managed to TURN THINGS AROUND in the Civil War? The Confederacy would still exist.
Until the American people stand up and demand that our leaders and the military junta running this country explain what they mean by these vague smokescreen terms, there will never be a true accounting.
————————————————————————————————————————————————
————————————————————————————————————————————————

Popularity: 1% [?]
Sphere: Related Content

It’s Bush thinking once again: “God Speaks Through Me,” said Bush on July 9, 2004 — the man who commands the greatest stockpile of nuclear missiles and other weapons of mass destruction ever created, believes that he is a prophet chosen by God to represent all that is good and right in the Universe…..Sarah Palin thinks in the same fashion!























































